Case Name |
Response on File |
Disposition |
Current Status |
Case Origin |
Jay M. Struve v. Wicomico County, Maryland, No. 07-338
|
Yes |
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Maryland |
Nabeel Muhammed Ashraf v. United States, No. 07-6538
|
Yes |
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Eleventh Circuit |
Derick Anthony Henry v. Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, No. 07-487
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
James R. Gibson v. United States, No. 07-506
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Seventh Circuit |
Agustin Aguayo v. Pete Geren, Secretary of the Army, No. 07-607
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
District of Columbia Circuit |
Venetian Casino Resort, LLC v. National Labor Relations Board, et al., No. 07-633
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
District of Columbia Circuit |
Phoenix of Broward, Inc. v. McDonald's Corporation, No. 07-659
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Solomon Vereen v. Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, et al., No. 07-667
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Georgia |
WFMJ Television, Inc. v. Catherine Bosley, et al., No. 07-716
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Illinois Bell Telephone Company v. International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local 21, No. 07-734
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Seventh Circuit |
Captain D's, LLC v. Tammy Smith, No. 07-799
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Mississippi |
Lindsey K. Springer v. Internal Revenue Service, ex rel. United States, No. 07-737
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Tenth Circuit |
Lindsey K. Springer v. Internal Revenue Service, ex rel. United States, No. 07-738
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Tenth Circuit |
Lindsey K. Springer v. Internal Revenue Service, ex rel. United States, No. 07-739
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Tenth Circuit |
Devin Daniels, et al. v. Philip Morris USA, Inc., et al., No. 07-740
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Puerto Rican Association of Beer Importers, Inc., et al. v. Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, et al., No. 07-748
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Supreme Court of Puerto Rico |
Charles W. Walker, Sr. v. United States, No. 07-749
|
Yes |
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Eleventh Circuit |
Shirley A. Graham v. Hartford Life and Accident Insurance Company, No. 07-763
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Tenth Circuit |
James D. Aljian, et al. v. Donald Johnson, No. 07-767
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Michael J. Kelly, Sr., et al. v. United States, No. 07-776
|
|
Redistributed |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Bernard Shaw, et ux., et al. v. City of Pasco, Washington, No. 07-788
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Washington |
James A. Shank, As Trustee of the Deborah J. Shank Irrevocable Trust, et al. v. Administrative Committee of the Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. Associates' Health and Welfare Plan, No. 07-791
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Eighth Circuit |
Camden-Clark Memorial Hospital Corporation v. Bernard Boggs, as Administrator of the Estate of Hilda Boggs, Deceased, No. 07-812
|
|
BIO Requested |
Denied |
West Virginia |
Marshall Spiegel v. Joanne Rowland, No. 07-864
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
New York |
Ohio Pyro, Inc., et al. v. Ohio Department of Commerce, Division of State Fire Marshal, et al., No. 07-868
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ohio |
Tom H. Whiteside v. Carr, Hunt & Joy, LLP, et al., No. 07-870
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Texas |
John L. Corrigan v. Unknown King County Deputy #1, et al., No. 07-876
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
James Widtfeldt v. Tax Equalization and Review Commission, et al., No. 07-877
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Nebraska |
Alexander Zinchenko v. Larry Scribner, Warden, No. 07-878
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
In Re David Sieverding, et ux., No. 07-884
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
|
Iowa v. James Howard Bentley, No. 07-886
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Iowa |
Susan Norris v. Jacquita Engles, Individually and In Her Official Capacity as an Employee of the Independence County Sheriff's Department, No. 07-887
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eighth Circuit |
PharmaStem Therapeutics, Inc. v. ViaCell, Inc., et al., No. 07-888
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Federal Circuit |
Nancy Alexander, et al. v. Bosch Automotive Systems, Inc., No. 07-891
|
Yes |
Redistributed |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Glacier Development Company, L.L.C., et al. v. Debra Miller, Kansas Secretary of Transportation, No. 07-900
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Kansas |
Shonta Michael v. Caterpillar Financial Services Corporation, No. 07-902
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Rohm and Haas Pension Plan v. Gary Williams, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, No. 07-906
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Seventh Circuit |
Kenneth W. Johnson v. Jesse Gadson, et al., No. 07-907
|
Yes |
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
District of Columbia Circuit |
Lessie Anderson, et al. v. Cagle's Inc., et al., No. 07-910
|
Yes |
Redistributed |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Winford Kent Bishop v. United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, No. 07-911
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Fifth Circuit |
Apotex, Inc., et al. v. Abbott Laboratories, No. 07-912
|
|
BIO Requested |
Denied |
Federal Circuit |
Ice Embassy, Inc., et al. v. City of Houston, Texas, No. 07-914
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Robert Brace v. United States, No. 07-916
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Federal Circuit |
Pamela Carvel, as Executor of the Estate of Agnes Carvel v. Carvel Foundation Inc., et al., No. 07-917
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Sarah Husain, et al. v. Marlene Springer, et al., No. 07-918
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Joshua Lewis Johnson v. North Carolina, No. 07-922
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
North Carolina |
Microsoft Corporation v. Novell, Inc., No. 07-924
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Paul Merritt Christiansen v. Bank of America National Trust and Savings Association, et al., No. 07-925
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Augusta N. Roman v. Randy M. Roman, No. 07-926
|
Yes |
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Texas |
Jenggi Kaluom v. Stolt Offshore Inc., No. 07-930
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Steven H. Untracht v. Erden Fikri, et al., No. 07-932
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
The Cadle Company v. Jack E. Pratt, Sr., No. 07-934
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
New York Mercantile Exchange, Inc. v. IntercontinentalExchange, Inc., No. 07-938
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Eyob Mamo, et al. v. District of Columbia, No. 07-942
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
District of Columbia |
Vikas Sareen v. Reema Sareen, No. 07-945
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Citizens United, Appellant v. Federal Election Commission, No. 07-953
|
Yes |
Redistributed |
Decided |
United States District Court for the District of Columbia |
Anesh Gupta v. Walt Disney World Company, No. 07-957
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Overview Books, LLC, et al. v. United States, No. 07-966
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Federal Circuit |
Deborah Kaye Parker v. Lee Edward Cumming, et al., No. 07-973
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Texas |
Ronald Vose v. Donald Kliment, et al., No. 07-975
|
|
BIO Requested |
Denied |
Seventh Circuit |
T-Mobile USA, Inc., et al. v. Jennifer L. Laster, et al., No. 07-976
|
|
BIO Requested |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Fitzroy Barnaby v. Illinois, No. 07-978
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Illinois |
Leonard William Houston v. Aames Funding Corporation, dba Aames Home Loan, et al., No. 07-979
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Syed Asad v. International Business Machines Corporation, No. 07-982
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Barbara Lessner v. United States, No. 07-1009
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Marlon Olivas v. California, No. 07-1013
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Perfect 10, Inc. v. Visa International Service Association, et al., No. 07-1026
|
|
BIO Requested |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Bradley Earl Hacker v. Thomas McBride, Warden, No. 07-1030
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
West Virginia |
Henk Rommy v. United States, No. 07-1031
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Alfred Campbell v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, No. 07-992
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Sixth Circuit |
Joan (Farr) Heffington, Individually and On Behalf of Major Jack G. Farr (U. S. A. F. Deceased) v. Department of Defense, No. 07-993
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Tenth Circuit |
Angel Vellon v. Louis S. Folino, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at Greene, et al., No. 07-1001
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Lajuana Destin and Denetra McElroy v. United States, No. 07-1044
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Robert M. Gates, Secretary of Defense, et al. v. Haji Bismullah, et al., No. 07-1054
|
Yes |
Redistributed |
Decided |
District of Columbia Circuit |
John J. Connolly, Jr. v. United States, No. 07-1058
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
First Circuit |
Carlos Jimenez v. Nathaniel Quarterman, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, No. 07-6984
|
Yes |
Argued |
Decided |
Fifth Circuit |
Kenneth Eugene Barrett v. United States, No. 07-7066
Capital
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Tenth Circuit |
Anniediabasi Dickson Obot, Sr., aka Anniediabasi Dickson Obot, aka Anniediabasi Obot v. United States, No. 07-7082
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Pierre Evans Simmons v. Shasta County, California, et al., No. 07-7103
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Ninth Circuit |
Jonathan B. Clark v. St. Joseph/Candler Health Systems, et al., No. 07-7233
|
Yes |
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Eleventh Circuit |
Brandon Lloyd v. Nathaniel Quarterman, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, No. 07-7272
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Fifth Circuit |
William Ward v. Illinois, No. 07-7277
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Illinois |
Leon Combs v. United States, No. 07-7335
|
Yes |
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Sixth Circuit |
Nathaniel Griggs v. Stephen Upton, Warden, No. 07-7340
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Eleventh Circuit |
Melvin Curtis Ellis, Jr. v. Texas, No. 07-7284
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Texas |
James Williams, Jr. v. Prince George's County, Maryland, et al., No. 07-7354
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Fourth Circuit |
Ludmyla Skorychenko v. Women's Community, Inc., et al., No. 07-7454
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Seventh Circuit |
Martin Christian Sorlien v. Michigan, No. 07-7462
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Michigan |
Patricia Ann Larson and Leon Nels Laverdure v. United States, No. 07-7481
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Randall B. Hofland v. Wendy L. Hofland, No. 07-7523
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
New Hampshire |
Michael G. Castaldo v. Colorado Industrial Claim Appeals Office, et al., No. 07-7540
|
Yes |
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Colorado |
Shawanda Murry v. Michael B. Mukasey, Attorney General, No. 07-7495
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Eleventh Circuit |
Curtis S. Thompson v. Robert Shilling, et al., No. 07-7505
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Ninth Circuit |
Brian T. O'Maley v. New Hampshire, No. 07-7577
|
Yes |
Redistributed |
Denied |
New Hampshire |
Harold Ven-Noy Davis v. Nathaniel Quarterman, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, No. 07-7589
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Fifth Circuit |
William A. Murray v. Nathaniel Quarterman, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, No. 07-7688
Capital
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Thomas Andrew Censke v. Marie Schartier, et al., No. 07-7750
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Sixth Circuit |
Thomas Andrew Censke v. Joe Lavey, II, et al., No. 07-7751
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Sixth Circuit |
Thomas Andrew Censke v. Mike Laurilla, et al., No. 07-7752
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Sixth Circuit |
In Re David Wayne Poydras, No. 07-7757
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
|
Deloris Burroughs v. BellSouth Telecommunications, Inc., et al., No. 07-7760
|
Yes |
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Eleventh Circuit |
Demond Poetry Beason v. United States, No. 07-7707
|
Yes |
Redistributed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Third Circuit |
Jacqueline Lorraine Holtz v. United States, No. 07-7723
|
|
GVR |
Decided |
Tenth Circuit |
Christopher Adam Geier v. California, No. 07-7770
Capital
|
Yes |
Redistributed |
Denied |
California |
Juan Carlos Martinez-Avina v. United States, No. 07-7807
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Daniel Lee Fortner and Joshua Cyrus Fortner v. Kentucky, No. 07-7822
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Kentucky |
Phillip Lacefield v. United States, No. 07-7831
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Sixth Circuit |
Jerome Henderson v. United States, No. 07-7837
|
Yes |
Redistributed |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Ritchie G. Kennedy v. United States, No. 07-7856
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Guillermo Rodriguez-Flores v. United States, No. 07-7948
|
|
GVR |
Decided |
Fifth Circuit |
Robert Valdez Leal v. United States, No. 07-7988
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Wade Bamberg v. United States, No. 07-7996
|
Yes |
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Eighth Circuit |
Omari Ali Zackery v. United States, No. 07-8034
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Eighth Circuit |
Steven Todd Ashworth v. United States, No. 07-8076
|
Yes |
Redistributed |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Martha Jacobs v. Internal Revenue Service, No. 07-8078
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Fourth Circuit |
Shondell E. Ingram v. United States, No. 07-8093
|
|
Redistributed |
Decided |
Eighth Circuit |
William Wallace v. Louis S. Folino, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at Greene, No. 07-8129
|
|
Redistributed |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Ronald Wheeler v. Ray Lawler, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at Huntingdon, et al., No. 07-8184
|
Yes |
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Third Circuit |
Darryl M. Durr v. Betty Mitchell, Warden, No. 07-8193
Capital
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Pedro Perez Neri v. Oregon, No. 07-8203
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Oregon |
Benjamin Bolin v. United States, No. 07-8167
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Lamar Barnwell v. California, No. 07-8168
Capital
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Margherita Underhill v. Long Beach Memorial Medical Center, et al., No. 07-8171
|
Yes |
Filing Fee Request |
Removed from Docket |
California |
Orvill Alamilla-Marvan v. United States, No. 07-8209
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
In Re James L. Tate, Jr., No. 07-8263
|
|
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
|
Harry Thomas Mitchell, II v. California, No. 07-8557
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Ahmad Peyravi v. Nathaniel Quarterman, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, No. 07-8577
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Gary Michael Benn v. Washington, No. 07-8578
|
|
BIO Requested |
Denied |
Washington |
Joseph William Dropalski v. Washington, No. 07-8579
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Washington |
Dwayne Chapman v. Bernard J. Fried, et al., No. 07-8581
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Malik J. Johnson v. Gerald L. Rozum, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at Somerset, et al., No. 07-8639
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Patrick Wayne Williams v. Burl Cain, Warden, No. 07-8643
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Kent Jones v. Steve Hood, et al., No. 07-8645
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Timothy David Murphy v. Frank Elo, Warden, No. 07-8646
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Halina Reid v. Robert Johnson, et al., No. 07-8648
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Virginia |
Frederick Eldred Renneke v. Nebraska Department of Health and Human Services, No. 07-8653
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Nebraska |
Richard A. Roundtree v. Gail Lewis, Warden, No. 07-8655
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
K. A. v. Sacramento County Department of Health and Human Services, No. 07-8656
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Javier Ochoa Canales v. Nathaniel Quarterman, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, No. 07-8665
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Fifth Circuit |
Todd Daniels v. Blaine Lafler, Warden, No. 07-8584
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Frank Nali v. United States District Court for the Western District of Michigan, No. 07-8586
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Keith Thomas v. AWI, et al., No. 07-8589
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Kia Tabatabaee, aka Casey Tabatabaee v. Georgia, et al., No. 07-8590
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Elwin Taylor, Jr. v. Anthony Hedgepeth, Acting Warden, No. 07-8591
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Kia Tabatabaee, aka Casey Tabatabaee v. Georgia, No. 07-8592
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Georgia |
Alvon Allen Thomas v. United States District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina, No. 07-8593
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Jose Rodriguez v. David Miller, Superintendent, Eastern Correctional Facility, No. 07-8594
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Daniel L. Spuck v. Paul J. Stowitzky, Superintendent, State Regional Correctional Facility at Mercer, et al., No. 07-8598
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Third Circuit |
Melvin Walker v. Texas, No. 07-8604
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Texas |
Dave A. Thomas v. Gene M. Johnson, Director, Virginia Department of Corrections, No. 07-8609
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Bobbie Sellers v. Mitch Daniels, Governor of Indiana, et al., No. 07-8612
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Seventh Circuit |
In Re Christopher Stoller, No. 07-8613
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
|
Juan Ramirez v. California, No. 07-8614
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Jesse Prather v. Texas, No. 07-8616
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Texas |
Daniel Charles Clarke v. California, No. 07-8619
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
California |
David W. Spencer v. Gene M. Johnson, Director, Virginia Department of Corrections, No. 07-8625
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Christopher Desmond v. Delaware, No. 07-8668
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Delaware |
Shawn Michael Ely v. Michigan, No. 07-8669
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Michigan |
Fernando DeLeon v. Texas, No. 07-8671
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Texas |
James Adams v. Corporal Stubbs, et al., No. 07-8675
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
James Adams v. Patricia Galloway, et al., No. 07-8676
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Danny Joe Boomershine v. Oklahoma, No. 07-8677
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Tenth Circuit |
Bryant Johnson v. Paul Annetts, Superintendent, Downstate Correctional Facility, No. 07-8681
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Robert Adams v. Ohio, No. 07-8685
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Ohio |
Charles R. Allen v. Ricky Bell, Warden, No. 07-8687
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Arrello Barnes v. Robert F. Henderson, et al., No. 07-8688
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Gregory Barnett v. Raymond D. Booker, Warden, No. 07-8689
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Monika Lateace McCain v. Clarice Stovall, Warden, No. 07-8690
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Roderick Deon Cole v. Alabama, No. 07-8692
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Alabama |
Acharmu Yazaid Crosby v. James E. Tilton, Director, California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, et al., No. 07-8697
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
In Re Victorio Rivera, No. 07-8699
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
|
David Tyrone Samuel v. John Marshall, Warden, No. 07-8700
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Milton Harris v. Raymond D. Booker, Warden, No. 07-8703
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
David M. Johnson v. Keebler-Sunshine Biscuits, Inc., aka The Keebler Company, No. 07-8706
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Third Circuit |
Archie Rodriguez v. James T. Wynder, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at Dallas, No. 07-8710
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Kiara Smith v. Ray Hobbs, et al., No. 07-8711
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eighth Circuit |
Robert Eugene Robinson v. California, No. 07-8713
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Mark F. Templeton v. Milo Pope, et al., No. 07-8716
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Burley Gilliam v. Walter A. McNeil, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections, No. 07-8725
Capital
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Joseph J. Filchock v. Ohio, No. 07-8729
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Ohio |
Donald Clinton Houghton v. Guy Hall, Superintendent, Two Rivers Correctional Institution, No. 07-8731
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Darius Gaines v. Darrel G. Adams, Warden, et al., No. 07-8733
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Federico De Jesus Estacio, Jr. v. Court of Appeals of Oregon, et al., No. 07-8740
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Lady Cage-Barile v. Church of Christ in Hollywood, et al., No. 07-8742
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
California |
James Douglas v. Sharon Blacketter, Superintendent, Eastern Oregon Correctional Institution, No. 07-8744
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Salahuddin F. Smart v. Township of Gloucester, New Jersey, et al., No. 07-8745
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Chadwick Willacy v. Florida, No. 07-8747
Capital
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Florida |
John Carter v. Donald L. Kelchner, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at Camp Hill, No. 07-8748
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Michelle Catherine Theer v. North Carolina, No. 07-8752
|
|
BIO Requested |
Rehearing Disposed |
North Carolina |
Gbeke Michael Awala v. Florida Department of Health, No. 07-8753
|
|
Dismissed |
Dismissed |
Florida |
James E. Knight v. Lisa M. Edwards, Warden, No. 07-8756
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
John E. Covington v. Mitsubishi Motor Manufacturing of America, Incorporated, et al., No. 07-8764
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Seventh Circuit |
Wise D. Allen v. Monique A. S. Allen, No. 07-8772
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
District of Columbia |
Martin Bramson v. S. M. Sulayman, et al., No. 07-8773
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Tony Wayne Cornett v. Nathaniel Quarterman, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, No. 07-8808
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Rufus J. Dickerson, Jr. v. James E. Donald, et al., No. 07-8809
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Eleventh Circuit |
Willie Riddick v. Marsha Modeny, et al., No. 07-8776
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Derran Smiley v. California, No. 07-8779
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Wayne Douglas Strickland v. Georgia, No. 07-8781
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Georgia |
Garrick G. John v. Florida, No. 07-8783
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Florida |
Joan B. Darlington v. Horace F. Darlington, Jr., No. 07-8815
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Pennsylvania |
Michael Aloyoues Larner v. Walter A. McNeil, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections, No. 07-8817
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Leonard H. Arline v. L. Kelly, Warden, No. 07-8820
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Corey D. Anderson v. Tony Parker, Warden, No. 07-8821
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Tennessee |
Okechukwu Mummee Amadi v. Federal Correctional Institutions Fort Dix Health Services, et al., No. 07-8822
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Sollog Immanuel Adonai-Adoni v. A. J. DeFino, et al., No. 07-8824
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Earnest Thorpe v. James Erwin, Warden, No. 07-8828
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Sixth Circuit |
Cesar Sarausad v. Doug Waddington, Superintendent, Washington Corrections Center, No. 07-8829
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
John Witherow v. Nevada Board of Parole Commissioners, et al., No. 07-8831
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Nevada |
Roberto Beras v. Charles A. Ross, No. 07-8835
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Clifton Morrow v. California, No. 07-8838
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Taek Sang Yoon v. R. Lopez, et al., No. 07-8839
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Antonio Saunders v. Brian Fischer, Commissioner, New York Department of Correctional Services, et al., No. 07-8851
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
James St. Louis v. Delaware, No. 07-8853
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Delaware |
Jimmy Saget v. Pennsylvania, No. 07-8877
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Pennsylvania |
Eric D. Norris v. Marilyn S. Brooks, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at Albion, No. 07-8885
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Dwight E. Lacy v. A. K. Scribner, Warden, No. 07-8901
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Liban Abdala v. Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al., No. 07-8906
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Robert Temple v. Marc Dann, Attorney General of Ohio, et al., No. 07-8914
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ohio |
Robert Drew v. Tony Parker, Warden, No. 07-8920
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Randall C. Gaess v. James Schomig, No. 07-8932
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Michael D. Forbes v. United States, No. 07-8934
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Larry Spears v. Gene M. Johnson, Director, Virginia Department of Corrections, et al., No. 07-8941
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Fourth Circuit |
Sopheap Chheang v. California, No. 07-8948
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Launeil Sanders v. Brian Lancaster, No. 07-8955
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
South Carolina |
Jerome Romey Sueing v. Michigan, No. 07-8958
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Michigan |
Gbeke Michael Awala v. City of Chicago, Illinois, et al., No. 07-8959
|
|
Dismissed |
Dismissed |
Seventh Circuit |
Richard Hirschfield v. Superior Court of California, Sacramento County, et al., No. 07-8962
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Trevor McDonald Bird v. James E. Tilton, Secretary, California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, et al., No. 07-8970
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Arkeem Bennett v. Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General of New York, et al., No. 07-8983
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Paul Edward Bunting v. David Bobby, Warden, No. 07-8984
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Tracey E. Donato v. New Jersey, No. 07-8992
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
New Jersey |
Theodore W. Oswald v. Wisconsin, No. 07-9012
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Wisconsin |
Arson I. Gibbs, Sr. v. Perry Phelps, Warden, et al., No. 07-9015
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Third Circuit |
LeAnne Soperla v. United States, No. 07-9033
|
|
GVR |
Decided |
Eighth Circuit |
Zara Ellis Sadler v. Barbara Claire Tilley, No. 07-9036
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Arthur Battle v. Hilton Hall, Warden, et al., No. 07-9045
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Ricardo Glover v. Judy P. Smith, Warden, No. 07-9050
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Seventh Circuit |
James Frazier v. Ohio, No. 07-9052
Capital
|
Yes |
Redistributed |
Denied |
Ohio |
Douglas Leigh Fauconier v. William Sondervan, et al., No. 07-9058
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Tomas D. Cuesta v. William Pollard, Warden, No. 07-9061
|
|
Dismissed |
Dismissed |
Wisconsin |
Pavel Kolar v. Michael B. Mukasey, Attorney General, No. 07-9074
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Dwight D. Handy v. Robert O. Lampert, Director, Wyoming Department of Corrections, et al., No. 07-9076
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Wyoming |
Mars L. Gore v. Walter A. McNeil, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections, No. 07-9078
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Joseph W. Finfrock v. Florida, No. 07-9083
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Florida |
James R. Foushee v. D. Wiggins, et al., No. 07-9091
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Scott James Eizember v. Oklahoma, No. 07-9097
Capital
|
Yes |
Denied |
Denied |
Oklahoma |
Patrick Alexandre v. Maine, No. 07-9106
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Maine |
James Aaron Cooper, III v. West Virginia, No. 07-9111
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
West Virginia |
Ronald Murray v. Edwards County Sheriff's Department, et al., No. 07-9116
|
|
BIO Requested |
Denied |
Tenth Circuit |
Lynne A. Wallenstein, aka Patricia Fletcher v. Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, No. 07-9118
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Pennsylvania |
William DiGianni v. National Evaluation Systems, Inc., No. 07-9140
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Michael A. Robinson v. United States, No. 07-9142
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Michael Dwayne Stigler v. Minnesota, No. 07-9144
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Minnesota |
Dennis Forbes v. United States, No. 07-9151
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Frederico Hatcher v. Thomas McBride, Warden, No. 07-9154
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
West Virginia |
Robert C. Comrie v. United States, No. 07-9167
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Sixth Circuit |
Montgomery Blair Sibley v. Supreme Court of Florida, et al., No. 07-9171
|
|
Filing Fee Request |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Scott C. Schaeffer-Duffy v. District of Columbia, No. 07-9174
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
District of Columbia |
In Re Bertha Marines, No. 07-9212
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
|
Duncan Burton v. Joe Young, Warden, No. 07-9215
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
William T. Hendricks, Jr. v. United States, No. 07-9218
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Horris Bernard Green v. United States, No. 07-9219
|
|
BIO Requested |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Nathaniel Rice v. United States, No. 07-9221
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Genaro Tony Rosales v. United States, No. 07-9222
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Abdias Rivera-Gonzalez v. United States, No. 07-9224
|
|
BIO Requested |
Denied |
First Circuit |
Gary L. Smith v. United States, No. 07-9225
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eighth Circuit |
Garfield George Patterson v. Maryland, No. 07-9226
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Maryland |
Charles Edward Turner v. California, No. 07-9230
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
California |
Michael Iver Peterson v. North Carolina, No. 07-9232
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
North Carolina |
James Edward Adamic v. United States, No. 07-9233
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Greg Long v. United States, No. 07-9234
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
Arturo Caballero v. United States, No. 07-9239
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eighth Circuit |
Patrick C. Mattete v. United States, No. 07-9240
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
District of Columbia |
Gazi Ibrahim Abu Mezer v. United States, No. 07-9243
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Randall White v. United States, No. 07-9244
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Raymundo Sandoval v. United States, No. 07-9248
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Antonio Allen v. United States, No. 07-9190
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Eliezer Rangel Ortiz, aka Eliezer Rangel v. United States, No. 07-9192
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Derwin Renwick McWaine v. United States, No. 07-9194
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Robert Edward Phillips v. United States, No. 07-9196
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Josephine Virginia Gray v. United States, No. 07-9200
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Stanley P. Jurgevich v. Colorado, No. 07-9204
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Colorado |
Frank Nason v. United States, No. 07-9206
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Tito Melvin v. United States, No. 07-9207
|
|
GVR |
Decided |
Second Circuit |
Augustin Abreu-Vasquez v. United States, No. 07-9209
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Elier Quinones-Muela v. United States, No. 07-9249
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
James Earl Smith v. United States, No. 07-9255
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Jose Edelmiro Mendieta-Garza v. United States, No. 07-9257
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Emil Joseph Long Neck v. United States, No. 07-9259
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Levi Love v. Ray Roberts, Warden, et al., No. 07-9264
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Tenth Circuit |
Shawn Leo Barth v. United States, No. 07-9273
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eighth Circuit |
Levi Wooderts, Jr. v. D. Berkebile, Warden, No. 07-9275
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Gilberto Guerrero-Ramirez v. United States, No. 07-9278
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Jocelyn Diaz v. United States, No. 07-9283
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Carol Denise Richardson v. United States, No. 07-9284
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Robert Joe Young v. United States, No. 07-9286
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Donny Ray Ward v. United States, No. 07-9288
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Jose Zaldivar-Fuentes v. United States, No. 07-9290
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Monroe White v. Arkansas, No. 07-9291
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Arkansas |
Robert Price, aka Bam, aka Gus v. United States, No. 07-9294
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Christopher M. Brown v. United States, No. 07-9298
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Luis Rafael Bat v. United States, No. 07-9299
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Corey Smith, aka Bubba v. United States, No. 07-9300
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Robert H. Dupes v. United States, No. 07-9302
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
John Ernest Dade v. United States, No. 07-9306
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
Ninth Circuit |
Aaron Ben Northrop v. Cameron Lindsay, Warden, No. 07-9311
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Christopher B. Williams v. United States, No. 07-9313
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Roland Mathis v. United States, No. 07-9319
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
James V. Lowery v. Michael J. Astrue, Commissioner of Social Security, No. 07-9326
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Alejandro Ramos Prodencio v. United States, No. 07-9328
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Jon R. Perroton v. United States, No. 07-9335
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Quiana N. Riggins v. United States, No. 07-9336
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Wallace Burks v. Randall Hepp, No. 07-9338
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Seventh Circuit |
Gerardo Zamora-Alvarez v. United States, No. 07-9340
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Rasan Townsend v. United States, No. 07-9343
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
James E. Lang v. Walter A. McNeil, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections, et al., No. 07-9344
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Andre Franz Lindsay v. United States, No. 07-9350
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Jonathan D. Nelson, aka Jody Nelson v. United States, No. 07-9352
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Edgerton Augustus Douglas v. United States, No. 07-9353
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
First Circuit |
Jorge Alberto Cordova-Barraza v. United States, No. 07-9354
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Nicolas Gonzalez v. United States, No. 07-9357
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Tracy Lamar Fisher v. United States, No. 07-9360
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Kevin Lee Johnson v. United States, No. 07-9365
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fifth Circuit |
Gail Denise Hutchinson, aka Gail Porter v. United States, No. 07-9367
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Aaron Foster, Keon Moses, and Michael Taylor v. United States, No. 07-9370
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Roberto Campos-Herrera v. United States, No. 07-9371
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Earl Dickerson v. United States, No. 07-9373
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
First Circuit |
Gary Lee Choate v. United States, No. 07-9374
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Sixth Circuit |
In Re Robert Lee Moore, No. 07-9378
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
|
Antone Porter v. United States, No. 07-9380
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Willy Anthony Oliver v. United States, No. 07-9381
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Eleventh Circuit |
Anthony McQueen v. United States, No. 07-9382
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
Otu Obot, et ux. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, No. 07-9385
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Second Circuit |
Roberto Cortez, Sr. v. United States, No. 07-9388
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Tenth Circuit |
Eric Adams v. Randy J. Davis, Warden, No. 07-9389
|
|
Dismissed |
Dismissed |
Seventh Circuit |
Alfred Boitnott v. United States, No. 07-9391
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
District of Columbia |
James McIntosh, aka Kareem "Bey" v. United States, No. 07-9392
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Third Circuit |
Ameen Abdul-Jillil v. United States, No. 07-9393
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Pablo Sereno-Villasenor v. United States, No. 07-9396
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Jesse Ian Smith v. United States, No. 07-9397
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Fourth Circuit |
In Re Kevin W. Mardis, No. 07-9433
|
|
Denied |
Rehearing Disposed |
|
In Re Steve Berry, No. 07-9442
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
|
In Re Andre J. Twitty, No. 07-9453
|
|
Dismissed |
Dismissed |
|
In Re Dallas R. Delay, No. 07-9469
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
|
In Re Sammy Lee Weatherspoon, Jr., No. 07-9484
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
|
Joshua Gunner Johnson v. United States, No. 07-9404
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
Burton Dean Viers and Kathi-Sue Wiechert v. United States, No. 07-9417
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
Ninth Circuit |
In Re John Henry Taylor, Jr., No. 07-9420
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
|
In Re James Dean Fuson, No. 07-9492
|
|
Denied |
Denied |
|
Daniel Girmai Negusie v. Eric H. Holder, Jr., Attorney General, No. 07-499
|
Yes |
Certiorari Granted |
Decided |
Fifth Circuit |
Federal Communications Commission, et al. v. Fox Television Stations, Inc., et al., No. 07-582
|
Yes |
Certiorari Granted |
Decided |
Second Circuit |
Luis E. Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts, No. 07-591
|
Yes |
Certiorari Granted |
Decided |
Massachusetts |
Gary Bartlett, Executive Director of the North Carolina State Board of Elections, et al. v. Dwight Strickland, et al., No. 07-689
|
Yes |
Certiorari Granted |
Decided |
North Carolina |
United States v. ABC, No. 07-745
|
|
BIO Requested |
Decided |
Second Circuit |
Cordell Pearson, et al. v. Afton Callahan, No. 07-751
|
Yes |
Redistributed |
Decided |
Tenth Circuit |
Doug Waddington, Superintendent, Washington Corrections Center v. Cesar Sarausad, No. 07-772
|
Yes |
Certiorari Granted |
Decided |
Ninth Circuit |
Betty E. Vaden v. Discover Bank, et al., No. 07-773
|
Yes |
Certiorari Granted |
Decided |
Fourth Circuit |
Lynn Hust v. Frank Marvin Phillips, No. 07-897
|
|
BIO Requested |
Decided |
Ninth Circuit |
Oregon v. Thomas Eugene Ice, No. 07-901
|
Yes |
Certiorari Granted |
Decided |
Oregon |
Republic of the Philippines, et al. v. Jerry S. Pimentel, Temporary Administrator of the Estate of Mariano J. Pimentel, Deceased, et al., No. 06-1204
|
Yes |
Argued |
Decided |
Ninth Circuit |
Richard Irizarry v. United States, No. 06-7517
|
Yes |
Argued |
Decided |
Eleventh Circuit |
Jaime Gustavo Gaytan-Gonzalez, aka Gaytan Jaime Gonzalez v. United States, No. 06-12099
|
Yes |
Rehearing Disposed |
Rehearing Disposed |
Ninth Circuit |